I USED TO argue with another reviewer about whether Robert
Altman was a genius or a very lucky idiot. The evidence for genius
would be films like Nashville (possibly the greatest American
movie of all time) and The Player. On the idiot side are
such embarrassments as O.C. and Stiggs and Quintet
(possibly the worst American film of all time). Further support
for the latter view comes from his recent interview in Entertainment
Weekly, where he claims that all of his most egregious movies
were simply misunderstood or ahead of their time (he says of critical
disaster Kansas City, "I predict that in a few years
it will wind up appreciated"; and he excuses his celebration
of the sexist degradation of the character "Hot Lips"
in the truly awful and overrated movie M*A*S*H* by saying,
"That isn't the way I treated her, that's the way I see her
being treated.")
However, in Cookie's Fortune he shows again his formidable
talent at filmmaking, hinting that the genius tag might just fit
after all.
The titular Cookie is an elderly white woman in Holly Springs,
Mississippi, where she decides it's time to join her deceased
husband in the afterlife. Unfortunately, her evil niece (played
as Cruella DeVil of the South by the increasingly annoying Glenn
Close) finds the body. Not wanting a suicide attached to her family
name, she arranges things so they look like murder. This leaves
Cookie's only friend, a black man who lives in her house and takes
care of her, as the suspect. The man, Willis Richland, is played
with such seamless subtlety by Charles Dutton that it's jarring
to have him transposed against the more theatrical acting of Close,
and Altman wisely keeps them in largely separate scenes.
Joining them are Julianne Moore as Close's mentally deficient
sister, and Liv Tyler as Moore's anomic daughter. Both give strong
performances, but Moore's is truly outstanding--she shines when
her character appears as the lead in the Holly Springs Easter
production of Oscar Wilde's Salome. Here you see Moore's
background in classical acting; and since her character is supposed
to be a bit insane, she's able to bring this stagey style into
the more subtle cinematic scenes without becoming camp.
Its strong performances aside, it's the small touches that make
Cookie's Fortune: a roll of police tape unraveling
to indicate a love scene, a cabinet door repeatedly creaking open,
Glenn Close's guilt comically symbolized by her hand in a cookie
jar full of sensitive documents. All of these images, and the
slow, steady and inventive camera work that are an Altman trademark,
set Cookie's Fortune apart from most movies, which use--even
if skillfully--a standard set of shots to convey their stories.
Perhaps Altman's wisest decision in making Cookie's Fortune was in not aiming too high. His attempts at broad social commentary have lately fallen flat, and here he takes a small story, with no pretensions to greatness, and executes it with extreme care. Maybe that's what genius is all about.